A system of injustice

May 14, 2015

How did we arrive at such a system of injustice?

I have met with many people who will describe themselves as anarchists or libertarians. They are frequently dismissed as nut cases with some utopian ideal of society that would never work. However, when it comes to criminal justice, they make some really great points.

What I see as one of the major problems in this country, as well as in others, is that we have given to men the power to create laws which in turn create crimes out of activites that some people do not approve of. We have given them such great power that not only can they create a crime out of an act that ultimately causes harm to another person, but we have given them the power to create a crime out of an act that causes absolutely no harm to any other person.

With this power, comes the ability for law makers to ban acts that they disapprove of. The danger of this is exaggerated by the fact that even in America's supposed democratic system where lawmakers are representatives of the people, the lawmakers decisions are not very well representative of the people.

This type of environment creates a crime out of things like smoking cigarettes, consuming marijuana, not wearing a seatbelt, engaging in consentual sex in exchange for money, fair gambling by-the-rules. It allows other acts to become crimes without paying for a right. For example, the freedom of assembly is frequently taxed by requiring a permit, and anyone attempting to organize an assembly without such a permit can be penalized. Failure to pay that penalty can result in the confiscation of property or imprisonment.

Now one may argue that wearing your seatbelt is a good idea. But should it be forced by law? Of course we know now that many of these laws are created as a way of increasing revenue for the government, but why do we allow it?

Now consider when, in an attempt to catch these criminals in the act, the government itself creates situations where these "crimes" will take place. They are literally creating the crime, then arresting a participant as the criminal.

Back to the libertarian or anarchist view, it is a crime in itself to make such laws. You are turning an ordinary act into a crime for the purpose of locking someone in prison or collecting a fine. It is not so much a utopian system where real crime such as theft and murder would cease to exist, it's simply a more just system where man can not criminalize and tax an activity that other people voluntarily conduct among themselves.

For example with gambling. This is one of the easiest to attack, because while gambling is illegal in most places in the US, there is always a legal lottery. Yes, the government will actually call gambling a crime, yet they will run the biggest gambling scheme of them all. If a group of people decide to gather and play a game of poker, where it would cost a specified amount to play, and the winner would walk away with the pot, where is the crime?

In our current system, this is a crime, simply because some people, whether a majority or minority with more political influence, have decided that other people should not participate in such an activity. Did it stop gambling from occuring? No, it simply drove it into black market, where people must meet in secret locations. Places where if someone is robbed, they would not be able to call the police to help them retrieve their property - a service which, criminal or not, every person has already paid for the privelege to.

In a libertarian/anarchist criminal justice system, gambling itself would not be a crime. Operating a casino in a way in which cheats would be a crime of fraud, because the expectation of the customers is that they will be paying for a fair game. Robbing someone outside of a casino would be a crime of theft, because it is the taking of someone elses property without consent. In a libertarian society, a victim of one of these true crimes would have the opportunity to seek justice by the government or by the public without the government.

I won't get into the detail of how anarchists describe their criminal justice system, but there are some well thought out plans for this. The point is that while one person might disapprove of gambling for any reason, it is a consentual act that does not have a victim. But in our current system, the government can actually use the claim by one person that it is a distasteful act as a means of creating a crime arbitrarily via legislation. They can then justify the use of military force by means of a SWAT team to raid an illegal place where gambling occurs. They can use this as a means to steal the property of both the gamblers and the house as their money is now "illegal". They can use this as a means to steal property, deeming a building a place of "illegal business", selling it at auction to the public for the benefit of the state.

Now most proponents of this, or at least those who are apathetic to it, will simply dismiss this as "yeah, but they were breaking the law".

But consider this. With absolutely no laws, would murder be a crime? What about theft? Of course they would, because it would be easy to see that these are both crimes where there is a victim. There doesn't need to be a law on the books, because it is obvious that you are taking something from someone that does not belong to you - life or property.

Now in such a system, there is a place where people go to gamble. This isn't illegal because there isn't any legislation against it. Now imagine where a group of people would break into such a place, and take property from all participants, evict the owners and auction the property to the public? Wouldn't this be the crime of theft?

So while we are used to such laws because it has long been the case, laws that have been passed since before I was born and also before many others were born, we are accostomed to it. But without a group of men writing on paper that the government may break into a place where men voluntarily gamble with eachother, take all their property, and use it for themselves or sell it to the public, this would simply be a crime in itself.

So what we have in our current justice system is a method where a group of men have actually legalized theft for their own benefit.

The libertarian or anarchist systems would not allow this. It would not put an end to cheats, but it would allow a victim of cheating to make public notice of it without being labeled as a criminal himself. It would not put an end to theft, but it would allow a victim to seek restitution without being labeled as a criminal himself.

There are many more crimes which operate in the same fasion. Many are traffic laws and drug laws. While it might be a good idea to follow these rules, it doesn't mean the government should have the right to steal your property because you forgot to put on your seatbelt, or decided to peacefully use marijuana in the privacy of your own home.

While these might not be behaviors that you would engage in, it's important to remember. While you can condone the use of government force to turn these acts into crimes, it is just as easy that others who disapprove of something you do could be converted into a crime. Perhaps it's talking on the phone while in line at a grocery store. This may seem farfetched, but we are already banning smoking while in public - something that could have easily been accomplished by people refusing to shop at places that allowed smoking - not by converting it into a crime.

These are things to consider, and while not everyone agrees with everything that libertarians or anarchists have to say, especially where they can't even agree among themselves, I do believe in the concept that the only system of justice that will work is one in which the only crimes are acts where there is a victim.

 


Stay up to date by subscribing to our mailing list:

Get your accountable authority tee shirt today!
Help keep Accountable Authority protecting the public from the police!
Donate!
Donations help pay for hosting costs and outreach! Or donate with bitcoin:
1G7wUeg4h32TPiJM15wVKaJKWLENk5hj9k

Recent Complaints

Officer: Duran, Not sure (NOT SURE.) Chicago Police Department, Chicago IL (CPD) 06/19/2015 Today on my way to the beach with my mother, we saw a dog get tossed out of a car. The dog was thrown onto a lawn and tumbled. The car slowed and never came to a complete stop. After the dog was thrown out of the passenger side window, the car sped up away. My mom began sobbing as I ran out of the car and grabbed the trembling dog. We were shocked that someone could be so cruel. At this point,... more...

Officer: Davis , Mary (INVESTIGATOR ) New York Attorney Greivence Committee 8th district , Buffalo NY (NY AGC8t) 05/17/2015 A legit complaint made against a mentally unstable district attorney. This committee is supposed to review complaint on any license attorney of New York. Since I shown mich evidence to prove it. This lady stated its not there capabilities to investigate. When the D.A. is obligated per United States Department of Justice to deal with issues of the local police corruption and also kidnappings. Both... more...

Officer: Semple, Craig (INVESTIGATOR) New York Attorney Greivence Committee , 8th District NY (NY AGC8t) 05/17/2015 I have made proper complaints to this agency against the District Attorney Michael Violante of Niagara County befpre and was lied to by investor Mary Davis stating they don't deal with a District Attorney. I called this guy said they deal with any one license to practice law in New York. He says now other nonsense. Covering for the back of him. Knowing the obligation that the District Attorney is... more...

Officer: Johnson/Greeneleaf, Jeremy/Eric (0112/0131) Scott Co. Sheriff's Dept., Scott KY (scsd) 04/27/2015 above... more...

Officer: Arcara, Richard (DISHONORABLE JUDGE) United States District Court Western Region of NY, buffalo NY (U.S.D.C.) 03/23/2015 I filed a legit case to The United States District Court Western District of New York in Buffalo New York. On September 12, 2014. Dishonorable Judge Richard Arcara . Has dismissed it. Making up false allegations, also put the conplaint under a false filong nature of suite as a 550 prisoner civil rights. When I was nlt a prisoner and it had nothing to do with any arrest. Clearly this judge is... more...

Officer: Kozak, Chief Bryan (CHIEF) Chey Wyoming , Cheyenne WY (P D) 02/08/2015 I was moving on May 25, 2013. Juan Carlos Mesa Barria broke into my car and broke into a locked box which contained 6 years of savings so my husband and I could buy a house. He stole every penny over the cost of the house leaving only enough to buy house. Any other thief would have stolen the entire box contents. On May 27 he had another accidental opportunity to get in that box. A simple... more...

Officer: Services, Warrants (UNKNOWN/REFUSED TO GIVE) Niagara Falls Police Warrants Division, Niagara NY (N.F.P.D.) 08/29/2014 At about 12:00 PM August 28, 2014, I went to the warrants department as told by the police officer who did attempt making proper police report, Clearly they are changing and messing with it. Or disregarding it totally. More like the guy at the desk at warrants department at 12pm does not know the laws or his job. He should have badge and license to carry weapon revoked indefinitely. Due to... more...

Officer: MALUCHNICK, PO (ID 17124) Niagara Falls Police Department, Niagara Falls/ Niagara NY (N.F.P.D.) 08/29/2014 A few times I went in person and this same officer refused to accept the ADAM WALSH ACT which mandates every law enforcement State, Federal, and Local Law Enforcement to enter the information of missing child into the "NCIC" National Crimes Information Center, with in 2 hours of report. Also the (PROTECT ACT) requires every Federal, State, and Local Law Enforcement to report case of missing child... more...

Officer: Violante, Michael (D.A.) District Attorney, Niagara NY (D>A.) 08/28/2014 Complaint on District Attorney of Niagara County Michael J. Violante The Attorney General said try to go to the D.A. if the police and the internal affairs are corrupt. I have called numerous times left messages no response in person they just say the DA is not there to take report. It is a police or family court matter. exactly proof they disregard laws just like the police and the State Police... more...

Officer: Nunley, Trey (65) Sheriff's Department, Rutherford TN (RCSO) 08/27/2014 Case # 69435 My father, suffering from a mental disorder, threatened to stab me with a screwdriver. Then my father called someone, to this day I still don\\\'t know who. (I suspect the neighbor) The argument my father had initiated that morning continued. I directed my mother to call the police. The Rutherford County Sheriff\\\'s Department arrives, I report my father\\\'s crime to deputy Michael... more...

Officer: Wojtsaszek-Gariano, Honorable Kathleen (N/A) Niagara Falls Family Court, Niagara Falls NY 08/19/2014 This is outrageous! A family court out of Niagara Falls New York is corrupted and or just gender biased, maybe my religion, maybe they are just against me in general. I know I have sent multiple complaints, to the wrong office on my mistake. I thought the 8th judicial Conduct since an office in Buffalo I could drop my complaint there, dealing with this courthouse. Now only they have acknowledged... more...

Officer: Violante, Michael (DA) District Attorney, Niagara Falls Niagara NY (D.A.) 08/14/2014 I keep requesting something be done about this international parental kidnapping clearly the D.A. is ignoring and refusing to do absolutely anything. Maybe due to the fact I am proving that the NFPD is corrupted. They clearly are trying to cover each other. So I attempted one last time to request and they just send me to voice mails. A waste of time and pointless to even attempt. No responses... more...

Officer: Cain, Carl (14-0043) Niagara Falls PD Internal affairs, niagara falls/ niagara NY (NFPD) 08/12/2014 The Niagara falls PD ignore kidnapping and international parental kidnapping.. proof my 2 children kidnapped to TX NOV 2012 abused neglected after long wait of family courts they refuse to do anything..Court orders disregarded by the police signed by a judge. Currently international parental kidnapping July 14,2014 my 2 month old at the time kidnapped to Canada even though the national center for... more...

Officer: Barrett, Toney (306) 08/11/2014 Officer Tony Barrett stating he followed two neighborhood kids who where throwing rocks entered my home without knocking, and walked into my bedroom.. the children closed the door behind them and went to get there mother. He informs the mother that if they where doing. After the mother agrees not to let the incident happen again, officer Barrett says "OK get the f**k out and don't let me see... more...

Officer: lewis, chris (?) drug task force, slayton/murray MN (buffalo ) 08/08/2014 I spelt some things wrong on my last compalaint so im gonna rewrite it.im on probation ,he showedup at my apt and said lets go for a drug test I said ok.when we got there he kept asking when i used last I said over a yaer .he said he didn't believe me and continued o asking questions about othwer people and grilling me about lieing .he was mainly looking for meth.when I asked what the test came... more...

Officer: lewis, Chris 46, slayton/ murray MN 08/08/2014 He halled Me in for a drug test cause I'm on probation and belittled me and didn't believe me when I said I wasn't using.he asked for my meds and gave me shit about how many I was on and if I should be driving on them.kept calling me a list.I passed the rest at the jail.and cause I thought he would tamper with it I went an hour later to the hospital and paid our of my own pocket for a drug test... more...

Officer: Jacob, joseph 28, orange NJ 08/07/2014 My boyfriend was falsely and brutaly arrest.... more...

Officer: lewis, chris 08/06/2014 Same as above harassment and accusations.... more...

Officer: Abanilla, Rolando (NOT KNOWN) Park Rangers, San Diego CA 08/05/2014 Officer Abanilla and his partner were responding to a complaint of loud noises coming from our campsite in the Cleveland National Forest. We rented it for the weekend and were in the middle of nothing but tree's and shrubs. We had a DJ playing music till about midnight but that ended and the noise had subsided. Officer Abanilla and 2 other rangers and 6 homeland security officers descended... more...

Officer: Quezada, None Given (2272) El Paso Police , El Paso TX (Dept) 08/05/2014 Ticketed for 3 violations ... more...